Bulletin Summary:
- Crackdown on Human Rights Voices with Publishing Complaints: Aida Seif El-Dawla Released on Bail.
- The Supreme Judicial Council Issues a Statement Regarding Lina Attalah’s Trial in the “Mada Masr” Case.
- 31 Years After the Incident: First Terrorism Circuit Refers the Case Files of Two Defendants to the Grand Mufti Ahead of Their Execution in the Egyptian Embassy Bombing in Islamabad Case .
- New Cairo Lawyers Reject Imposing Fees on Case Decision Inquiries, and the Court President Backs Down
- Amid Protests and Unrest: 13 Prisoners Transferred from Abu Zaabal to Minya Maximum Security Prison.
Bulletin Items:
First. Public Prosecution Investigations:
- Crackdown on Human Rights Voices with Publishing Complaints: Aida Seif El-Dawla Released on Bail
On November 9, the Cairo Appeals Prosecution, at the Prosecutor General’s Office in Al-Rehab City, summoned Dr. Aida Seif El-Dawla for questioning regarding complaints filed against her by 16 lawyers. She was accused of publishing false news and statements inside and outside the country, following her reposting last October of a statement issued by several Egyptian political parties concerning the “Battle of Empty Stomachs” (hunger strike) inside prisons. After hearing her testimony, the prosecution decided to release her on bail set at 50,000 EGP. Taking her health conditions into consideration, the head of the prosecution directed that the defense team be enabled to pay the bail and finalize her release procedures inside the prosecution’s premises, without the need to escort her under security guard to the police station.
The summoning of Aida Seif El-Dawla comes in the context of targeting several human rights defenders and activists based on complaints filed by individuals of unknown standing or motives. This opens the door to using criminal complaints as a tool to pressure human rights voices, especially amid ongoing crackdowns on human rights defenders and the expression of opinions and stances related to public affairs. Conversely, the Cairo Appeals Prosecution is credited with taking Seif El-Dawla’s health conditions into account when deciding to release her, and the head of the prosecution’s directive to finalize her release procedures from the prosecution’s headquarters rather than transferring her to a police station.
Pretrial Detention and Its Violations:
- Detention of Director Omar Salah and TikToker “Mohamed Allam” (Known as Rivaldo) Renewed in Absentia Amid Lost Connection with Their Prisons
On November 11, the Second Terrorism Circuit of the Cairo Criminal Court, convened at the Badr Courts Complex and presided over by Counselor Wagdy Abdel Moneim, with the membership of Counselors Abdel Galil Muftah and Diaa Amer, decided to renew the pretrial detention of director Omar Salah Marei for 45 days pending Supreme State Security Case No. 3383 of 2026, and TikToker Mohamed Allam, known as “Rivaldo,” for 45 days pending Supreme State Security Case No. 9 of 2025. This occurred despite the inability to establish communication with the prisons where the two detainees are being held.
The decision to renew their detention comes amid an inability to communicate with the detainees during the review of their detention renewal order, highlighting the importance of examining the availability of necessary procedural safeguards to exercise the right of defense. In particular, the renewal of pretrial detention should not turn into a routine procedure tied to periodic schedules, but rather must be based on genuine judicial oversight of the justifications for the continued deprivation of liberty and the fulfillment of its legal conditions.
Second. Trials:
In the first half of November 2026, approximately 1,799 citizens were tried across 48 cases—mostly state security felonies—before terrorism circuits at the “Badr Court Complex in Badr Prison” and the New Cairo Misdemeanors Court. Some of these trials witnessed legal anomalies and a lack of fair and equitable trial standards, including:
- 31 Years After the Egyptian Embassy Bombing in Islamabad: Referral of Two Defendants’ Papers to the Mufti Ahead of Their Execution Sentences:
On November 5, during two trial sessions, the First Circuit of the Cairo Criminal Court—convened at Badr Prison and presided over by Counselor Mohamed Said El-Sherbiny, with counselors Wael Omran and Ghareeb Ezzat—referred the papers of two defendants in Case No. 4228 of 2026, felonies of the Gamaliya precinct, popularly known as the “Islamabad Egyptian Embassy Bombing” case, to the Grand Mufti of the Republic for religious legal opinion on their execution, setting December 23, 2026, as the date to pronounce judgment.
The trial procedures took only two sessions before the court decided to refer the defendants’ papers to the Mufti, in a procedural path of utmost gravity that could end in the death penalty. This speed raises questions about trial procedures, the adequacy of time available to examine prosecution evidence, and the empowerment of the defense to discuss it in a manner that demands pause. This is especially true since the soundness of criminal judgments is inseparable from the soundness of the procedures preceding them, and fair trial guarantees require enabling defendants to mount a serious and effective defense, subjecting the case evidence to sufficient scrutiny before reaching a verdict with irrevocable consequences.
- Due to Events of a Previous Case, Lina Attalah’s Defense Team Requests the Recusal of Judge Mohamed Mubarak On November 11, the Ninth Circuit of the New Cairo Misdemeanors Court, presided over by Counselor Mohamed Mubarak, adjourned the trial of journalist Lina Attalah in Case No. 3219 of 2024, misdemeanors of the First New Cairo precinct—where she is accused of publishing false news and statements and operating a website without a license—to November 18, 2026, to take steps for the recusal of the court, based on a request by the defense team. The recusal request stems from the fact that the same judge had earlier this month issued a verdict fining Lina three million pounds in a similar case and detained her inside the court after deciding to assign a lawyer to defend her despite her objection and insistence on her original defense team. The recusal request gains special importance in light of the facts cited by the defense team regarding the trial proceedings in another case concerning the journalist, particularly the refusal to record defense requests in the session minutes and the assignment of another lawyer despite the presence of the original defense team and their readiness to perform their duties.
Third: The Judiciary
- The Supreme Judicial Council Issues a Statement Regarding Lina Attalah’s Trial in the “Mada Masr” Case
On October 31, the Supreme Judicial Council issued a statement regarding Case No. 11743 of 2026, New Cairo Misdemeanors, in which journalist Lina Attalah, editor-in-chief of the “Mada Masr” website, is accused of establishing and operating an unlicensed electronic website. The statement clarified that the court granted the defendant the right to defense, as recorded in the session minutes, and decided to assign a lawyer for her after her defense requested an adjournment to review the case files. It also mentioned that she waived in writing her right to appeal the verdict, which sentenced her to a three-million-pound fine, the closure of the website, and the confiscation of its equipment. However, fair trial guarantees are not achieved merely by the presence of a lawyer or the appointment of a defense counsel; rather, they require empowering the defense to examine the case files, prepare their defense, and effectively discuss the prosecution evidence. As for waiving the appeal, it is legally established that the forfeiture of the right to appeal is linked to the expiration of the legal deadlines prescribed for undertaking it. One must not confuse the forfeiture of the right to appeal with waiving it, as each has its own legal provisions and effects. The transparency of procedures and respect for defense rights remain a fundamental right that does not conflict with the independence of the judiciary or respect for its rulings; rather, it represents one of the foundations upon which trust in justice rests.
Fourth: Lawyers
- New Cairo Lawyers Reject Imposing Fees on Case Decision Inquiries, and the Court President Backs Down
On November 5, the headquarters of the New Cairo Court of First Instance witnessed a gathering of lawyers protesting a decision by the court president to impose financial fees in exchange for inquiring about decisions issued in rental cases and civil lawsuits. The lawyers’ protest resulted in the cancellation of the decision, as the court president clarified that the purpose of the measure was not to collect money, but rather to organize the workflow within the court. Inquiring about judicial decisions and procedures is an essential part of the right to defense and lawyers’ performance of their professional duties. Services related to tracking lawsuits should not turn into additional financial burdens that hinder lawyers and litigants from accessing the information necessary to exercise their rights. Furthermore, organizing work within the courts, despite its importance, must be done through administrative mechanisms that do not impose fees without a legal basis, and it should not lead to restricting lawyers’ rights to follow up on cases and review the decisions issued therein. The retreat from this decision underscores the importance of lawyers standing firm for their professional rights and their role in confronting administrative measures that may infringe upon the right to litigation or obstruct the proper administration of justice.
Fifth: Prisons and Prisoners
- Amid Protests and Unrest: 13 Prisoners Transferred from Abu Zaabal to Minya Maximum Security Prison
On November 12, the “Gwar” foundation published a post on its social media page on Facebook reporting that the Abu Zaabal prison administration arbitrarily subjected 13 prisoners to “taghreeb” (forced internal deportation/transfer) and transferred them to the Minya Maximum Security Prison, amid a state of unrest and protests among the prisoners against these measures. According to the foundation, the transfer of the prisoners took place amidst an atmosphere of tension inside the prison, with a number of detainees protesting the transfer procedures, while no additional details have yet become available regarding the reasons for their transfer or the circumstances surrounding the decision. This incident sheds light on the issue of prisoner transfers (“taghreeb”) and the consequences it entails that go beyond merely moving a detained person from one place of detention to another—especially when the transfer is carried out suddenly or without clarifying its reasons to the detainees and their families. Such transfers increase the suffering of the prisoner and their family due to the remoteness of the detention facility, the difficulty of visitation, and the disruption of the prisoner’s living conditions.